The Role of Higher Education in Economic Mobility: A Focus on Community and Intergenerational Opportunity
gregpillar
on
August 24, 2024
Economic mobility, particularly intergenerational mobility, is a crucial component in addressing disparities in opportunity and improving the well-being of communities. Higher education institutions are often positioned as key vehicles for upward mobility, providing individuals with the skills and credentials needed to move up the economic ladder. However, recent research and local insights suggest that higher education’s role in supporting mobility goes beyond individual academic achievement; it also requires a commitment to fostering thriving communities where children can grow, learn, and develop the social capital necessary for long-term success.
About 10 years ago Charlotte found itself in an undesirable position due to a 2014 study that highlighted its ranking as one of the worst cities in the U.S. for economic mobility (50/50). According to that study, children born into poverty in Charlotte had only a 4-5% chance of climbing to the top income bracket, sparking concern among community leaders, educators, and policymakers. This sobering statistic led to a range of initiatives aimed at addressing systemic barriers to upward mobility. Now, a recent follow-up study led by the same researcher, Dr. Raj Chetty, provides updated data showing that Charlotte’s growth and various targeted efforts may be starting to pay off. In this post, I’ll explore the new findings that were presented by co-author Dr. Benjamin Goldman in their research, analyze what’s changed in Charlotte, and discuss the critical factors contributing to this improved outlook. While progress is being made, there are still challenges ahead that must be carefully navigated and a definite role for institutions of higher education in this work.
Understanding Intergenerational Mobility and Community Impact

Panel discussion following Dr. Benjamin Goldman’s presentation: “Changing Opportunity: Understanding The Data Behind The Latest Economic Mobility Study” hosted by UNC-Charlotte, Leading on Opportunity, and the Gambrel Foundation (Photo by Ashley Mahoney – Axios)
Research from Opportunity Insights shows that economic mobility in the U.S. is highly dependent on the environment in which children grow up. Stable neighborhoods, access to quality education, and strong community networks are significant predictors of whether children can surpass their parents’ economic status. Recent studies have shown mixed progress in this area: while racial gaps in economic mobility have narrowed by 27%, class gaps within racial groups—especially among White children—have widened significantly, reflecting growing income disparities. This underscores the importance of addressing systemic inequalities at both the individual and community levels.
At a recent forum hosted by the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and Leading on Opportunity, Benjamin Goldwater of Opportunity Insights highlighted the influence of community conditions on economic outcomes. According to Goldwater and the panel of experts, communities that invest in social infrastructure, such as strong schools, job opportunities, and health resources, create environments where children have a better chance of achieving upward mobility. Conversely, communities plagued by joblessness, segregation, and inadequate social services often trap families in cycles of poverty, even when education is accessible.
Dr. Goldman’s presentation and the related report noted the following key findings:
- Reduction in Racial Gaps: The study found that the Black-white gap in upward economic mobility has shrunk by 27% since 2007. This reduction is driven mainly by improved outcomes for Black children born into low-income families, particularly in regions historically disadvantaged for Black Americans.
- Growing Class Gaps Among White Americans: While racial gaps have narrowed, class gaps among white Americans have grown by 28%. White children from low-income families born in 1992 have worse economic outcomes compared to those born in 1978, while outcomes for white children from high-income families have improved.
- Shifts in the Geography of Opportunity: Traditional regions of upward mobility, such as coastal cities, have seen a decline in economic opportunity for low-income white children, while improvements have been noted in areas like the Southeast and Midwest for Black children. For instance, Charlotte saw significant gains in mobility for Black children, reaching near national averages, while similar cities like Atlanta showed little change.
- Role of Social Environments: The study emphasizes that the changes in economic mobility are closely tied to the communities where children grow up. Employment rates of parents in these communities, especially those of the same race and class, are strongly correlated with children’s outcomes.
- Social Interactions as a Key Driver: The research highlights that social interactions and networks within communities play a crucial role in shaping economic mobility. For instance, children’s outcomes are most influenced by the employment status of parents within their immediate peer group.
- Policy Implications: The findings suggest several strategies to improve economic opportunity, including focusing on youth development programs, targeting interventions at community levels rather than just neighborhoods, and investing in social capital alongside financial and human capital.
The report underscores the dynamic nature of economic opportunity, demonstrating that while some barriers can be overcome in a relatively short time, the persistence of challenges—especially those tied to class—calls for targeted and scalable policy solutions.
Higher Education’s Role in Supporting Community-Level Change
Given the importance of community in determining economic outcomes, higher education institutions must rethink their role in society. Universities can contribute to economic mobility not only by educating students but also by actively engaging with and supporting the communities around them. This involves several key strategies:
- Embedding Community Engagement into Academic Programs: Universities can integrate service learning, community-based research, and internships that directly address local needs. These programs not only enrich the educational experience but also strengthen the social fabric of surrounding neighborhoods by building connections between students and local residents.
- Providing Holistic Support for Students and Families: Economic mobility is closely tied to social support systems. Universities should offer resources like mentoring, mental health services, and career counseling that extend beyond academic guidance. By fostering a sense of community and belonging, institutions can help students from low-income backgrounds navigate challenges that might otherwise hinder their success.
- Collaborating with Local Government and Nonprofits: Effective interventions require collaboration across sectors. Higher education institutions should partner with local governments, nonprofits, and businesses to address systemic barriers like transportation, housing, and healthcare. For instance, public transit initiatives in Charlotte have been highlighted as critical for connecting residents in underserved areas to job and educational opportunities.
What This Means for Charlotte.
Charlotte’s progress in economic mobility is a promising sign, moving from being ranked 50th to 38th in recent studies. However, much work remains to be done to ensure that all residents, especially those in historically marginalized communities, have the opportunity to thrive. My institution, Queens University of Charlotte, can play (and has played) a pivotal role by continuing to engage with local challenges and integrating/threading community impact into its academic mission.
Supporting Place-Based Initiatives: By expanding programs that address food insecurity and access to resources in underserved neighborhoods, Queens can contribute to reducing disparities in opportunity. Collaborating with local organizations to provide educational resources, health services, and social support in high-need areas can create more equitable conditions for all residents.
Building Bridges Between Students and the Community: Expanding initiatives like the “State of the Plate” report and food redistribution projects can deepen the university’s impact while providing students with hands-on learning experiences that cultivate civic responsibility and leadership.
A couple of examples of community based work that I was fortunate to have been involved with includes a partnership with the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Food Policy Council.
“State of the Plate” Report and Food Insecurity Mapping: Students and faculty from Queens University of Charlotte played a crucial role in the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Food Policy Council’s “2015 State of the Plate” report, which focused on addressing food insecurity and food deserts in the region. Queens students and faculty contributed by assisting with GIS mapping to identify areas with limited access to fresh food. Their involvement helped uncover disparities in food availability and laid the groundwork for targeted interventions to improve food access in underserved communities.
Honors Capstone Project on Food Redistribution: In an Honors capstone course, Queens students tackled the challenge of connecting surplus food from local farmers’ markets to people experiencing food insecurity. The project aimed to create a sustainable system where excess food could be redistributed while also providing compensation to farmers. By engaging students in real-world problem-solving, the university not only contributes to addressing local issues but also provides valuable experiential learning opportunities that enhance students’ understanding of community needs.
A Path Forward
Economic mobility is not solely about individual effort; it is deeply influenced by the collective conditions of communities. For higher education to be a true catalyst for intergenerational mobility, institutions must embrace a holistic approach that considers the broader social, economic, and infrastructural contexts. By investing in both their students and the communities they inhabit, universities like Queens University can make meaningful contributions toward closing gaps in opportunity and fostering lasting change within their community and beyond.
Citations
- Charlotte-Mecklenburg Food Policy Council 2015 State of the Plate Report. [https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EqoS4tEAKJDbhD4EN54LICkSjsZqzoiB/view].
- Chetty, R., et. al. Is the United States Still a Land of Opportunity? Recent Trends in Intergenerational Mobility, Working Paper 19844, January 2014. [https://opportunityinsights.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/mobility_trends.pdf ]
- Chetty, R., et al. Changing Opportunity: How Changes in Children’s Social Environments Have Increased Class Gaps and Reduced Racial Gaps in Economic Mobility. Opportunity Insights, July 2024. [https://opportunityinsights.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/ChangingOpportunity_Nontech.pdf]
- Goldwater, B. (2024). Presentation at “Changing Opportunity: Understanding the Data Behind the Latest Economic Mobility Study” Forum. Hosted by UNC Charlotte and Leading on Opportunity, August 2024. Personal copy in possession of the author.
[https://opportunityinsights.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/ChangingOpportunity_Slides.pdf] - Mahoney, A. “Transportation Investment Key to Improving Economic Mobility in Charlotte, UNC Charlotte professor says.” Axios Charlotte, August 23, 2024. [https://www.axios.com/local/charlotte/2024/08/23/transportation-investment-improving-economic-mobility-charlotte].
- Robins, K. “Charlotte is making progress on economic mobility, Harvard-based research group finds” The Charlotte Observer, July 26, 2024. [https://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/local/article290424434.html].
- Sands., A. “Exclusive: Charlotte no longer 50th out of 50 for economic mobility, new Chetty study shows.” Axios Charlotte, July 25, 2024 [https://www.axios.com/local/charlotte/2024/07/25/charlotte-economic-mobility-ranking-chetty]